Episode Transcript
[00:00:00] Speaker A: One of the biggest mistakes that a brand can make is like treating influencer marketing as a transaction. We rely heavily on thousands of creators that we've worked with. Creator selection is much more sophisticated than just looking at follower count. The customer journey isn't linear, so what channel gets credited for that sale? Platform metrics. The metrics measure attention.
Business metrics measure impact. Another thing that's increasingly important is audience portability.
[00:00:33] Speaker B: Welcome to The Entrepreneur's Logbook Podcast. I'm your host Zach Bernard. You can find me on Social Zack B. In each episode I bring on experts from various industries for you to learn about their strategies and insights driving extreme business growth. Today we're joined by Paula Bruno, founder and CF Intuition Media Group, an independent influencer marketing agency that helps brand build creator led campaigns rooted in cultural relevance and measurable business outcomes. Funny enough, Paula actually launched her company back in 2008 before the like influencer marketing side of things was even a thing to put it very simply. Making her one of like the earliest like practitioner in a space that most brand are still trying to like figure out today. To put it simply. And over the past 18 years she's managed campaign for brands like Canon USA, Hyundai, TikTok and GoDaddy generating over 3 billion impressions across more than a thousand brand project. She was also the first agency to activate creators around TikTok's US launch back in 2018 before it blew up. And everyone knows about TikTok now. She's also co founded Blizzdom Events which became the second largest social media influencer conference in the US and the largest in Canada. Paula, it's great to have you on the show. Welcome aboard.
[00:01:49] Speaker A: Thanks so much. Thanks for having me. Looking forward to digging in.
[00:01:52] Speaker B: Me too. I'm really excited because we've had a lot of people like marketing but influencer marketing is probably one of the main things that we have not touched a lot on and we're going to dive all about that in a couple seconds here. But one of the first things I always like to ask anyone that comes on your show as it is a business, it is an entrepreneurship podcast is if you have to like rebuild your company from scratch, knowing everything that you know today, what's maybe the one thing that you feel you would do differently?
[00:02:18] Speaker A: Oh wow.
What would I do differently if I had to build it from scratch?
That's a tricky question because I mean I think that you know, I think we've built smart, you know, we've built the company in a way that is can take advantage of, you know, being an independent company. Therefore, we can, you know, pivot pretty quickly and move when we need to.
So I think, you know, I think if we had to make one change, you know, maybe that would be, you know, with regards to specific hiring practices, you know, and really, I think because talent, for me, having the right team is super important, and I do have a great team, I think I would pro. There's been a little bit of a hiccup over the last year with one or two people, and I think what I would probably do is get like a recruiter or someone who's very experienced in interviewing to help me with the interviews.
[00:03:39] Speaker B: Yeah, that's fair. I mean, talent is a big part of, like, every single business.
[00:03:43] Speaker A: You want
[00:03:43] Speaker B: to make sure that you get the good talent
[00:03:45] Speaker A: to make sure you can grow
[00:03:46] Speaker B: some hassle.
I agree with you. I think it's an area that everyone could improve here. But one thing I'd love to dive in a little bit for someone who has new work with an influencer marketing agency. Maybe they've heard of the concept of influencer marketing, but not really sure how that works. I'd love to kind of understand what that actually looks like. When a brand comes to you guys from the moment they become a client, how do you guys, like, support them, like, help them?
[00:04:13] Speaker A: Yeah, I think one of the biggest, like, misconceptions about influencer marketing and working with an agency is that our job is really simply to find influencers and then pay them. Right. And that's actually a very small part of what we do. I think when a brand comes to Intuition Media Group, the first thing we do is we really try to understand the business. And I mean, you know, what are they. What are they trying to accomplish? Are they launching a product? Are they trying to reach new audience?
Do they have another tent pole?
Are they trying to change perceptions or is it driving sales?
Because all of those are very different objectives and they require different strategies.
So from there, we look at, you know, the audience, what they're doing, who are they, you know, who are. Who's influencing decisions, where are they spending time, what platform seems to be the most prevalent.
And most importantly, then we look at the creators who've earned the audience trust. Right? And then we build the strategy, the creators, the right creators, the platforms, the creative concepts, the content format, and then the distribution plan. So I think, you know, it's. There's. There's a lot that goes into it, and creator selection is much more sophisticated than just looking at follower counts. Right. We're really trying to evaluate Audience demographics, engagement, quality, whether or not there are bot followings, brand alignment, how is their content performing, and whether the influencer can credibly communicate the brand's message, whatever that message might be.
And then really, I'm talking about the whole process. So we do creator selection once we've identified the creators, and we manage everything from there.
Outreach, negotiations, contracts, creative briefings, approvals, content productions, fc, FTC compliance, execution, reporting.
[00:06:26] Speaker B: A lot.
[00:06:27] Speaker A: Yeah, a lot. Right. And then, you know, increasingly, you know, recently, you know, we've also been getting involved. You know, it doesn't really stop when the content goes live. Right. We're, we're increasingly helping brands amplify creator content through paid media, which is, you know, which involves, like, testing different creative approaches, understanding which investments are actually moving the needle.
So that's another area that we're focused on.
[00:06:55] Speaker B: Yeah. Because I feel like a lot of people when they're looking at, like, influencers, like, they're like, oh, someone has a million followers, must be an amazing person to post your product. But that's just like one of, like, the layers. And then you want to go look at the engagement. And even if someone has a good engagement, it might not mean that their audience will be willing to buy, like, your product or, like, be that. Right. Demographic. So it looks like you guys take a very strategic approach, like digging beyond just like the followers, the engagement. You really want to, like, understand, like, who those demographics are, who those people are. Maybe what's like, the psychology behind that? Are they actually going to buy?
[00:07:32] Speaker A: Exactly. Do they have the trust of their audience? Right. And another, another thing that's increasingly important, and I touched upon this in a, in a recent newsletter, is audience portability. Right.
And that's key. Does your audience, does the audience follow the creator from one platform to another?
Meaning will it go from TikTok to Instagram? From Instagram to a substack. Right. Will they buy something? Will they. Are they interested in the influencers? Quote, Mer, maybe that they have. Right. So that's another really key piece of, piece of information.
[00:08:10] Speaker B: Yeah, like a very, like, loyal following. Because
[00:08:13] Speaker A: you
[00:08:13] Speaker B: talked about the trust, which is, like, very important, but, like, loyal. Like, they'll follow you like any platform. It's like cult, in a way.
[00:08:20] Speaker A: Yeah. They're super fans. Right? They're. They're your super fans. They follow you everywhere.
[00:08:25] Speaker B: I love that. So those are the type of people that you want to find and you
[00:08:28] Speaker A: guys
[00:08:29] Speaker B: really help them find that. And then I know you help with, like, contracts and everything like that, so you dive like very in like the deep end to make sure
[00:08:36] Speaker A: we're in the weeds. Yeah, we're in the weeds of everything. Yeah, yeah.
[00:08:40] Speaker B: And I guess like when someone thinks about like for example, like a brand, like one thing I hear pretty often is that they never know if an influencer campaign is actually working. Like the attribution across like a lot of the social media platform, it kind of looks like maybe it's a bit harder to track. And I'd kind of love to hear from your perspective, like how you guys approach that. Because every brand, they're like, oh, if I put some money in, how am I going to track what I'm getting out of it? And if I'm paying an influencer, for example, like how do I measure that?
[00:09:08] Speaker A: Right. I think attribution for me is really one of the most misunderstood areas of influencer marketing.
[00:09:15] Speaker B: Sure.
[00:09:16] Speaker A: The challenge is, is that the customer journey isn't linear. Right. It's not linear anymore. Someone might discover your product through TikTok, but then they may go watch a YouTube video two weeks later or three weeks later, then they might see an Instagram ad and then they might do a search on Google and ultimately make it make a purchase. So what channel gets credited for that sale? And I think that's where it gets complicated.
Each platform has their own measurement system and their attribution, windows, etc.
You also have privacy restrictions and cross device behavior, so it makes it really, really hard to see where the final purchase came from.
And just because I always tell a brand that's like, just because you can't directly attribute conversion to a creator doesn't mean that the creator didn't influence the funnel. Right? So I think it's it. What we do is we really define, you know, what is, what does success mean for the brand? You know, it could be awareness. If it's awareness, we look at reach, we look at impressions, we look at, you know, audience sentiment. Recently we've been doing brand lift studies and trying to see whether or not the perceptions are changing.
On the other hand, if the objective is consideration or conversion, then we're going to be looking at different things, Right. We're going to be looking at not only website traffic, right? We're going to be looking for search behavior, content engagement, and then we're going to be looking at conversion rates, return on ad spend, etc. So we do use, you know, tracking links, platform data, data, excuse me, in paid media, reporting and other measurement tools. But it's still, you know, really trickly tricky when you're trying to build attribution to a specific creator.
[00:11:27] Speaker B: Yeah. It's interesting because I spoke to someone else like, a while ago. They were talking about, like, attribution. Like, you never know, like, sometimes a bit hard to track, but it's like, hey, like, if you turn off this channel, though, maybe the rest of the other channel are not going to perform as well.
[00:11:41] Speaker A: Right, right. You
[00:11:42] Speaker B: have to keep that in mind with your marketing efforts here. I want to touch.
[00:11:45] Speaker A: I mean, I also just want to say that, like, platform metrics, the metrics measure attention, right?
[00:11:52] Speaker B: Yeah.
[00:11:53] Speaker A: Business metrics measure impact. So I think the real challenge for me in brands is really understanding how the two connect,
[00:12:05] Speaker B: the integration in a way. I like that. I want to touch on to something that I saw when I was doing a little bit of my research before that we spoke and you've developed a pretty, like, unique model, like the IC4. I think that's like what you call it, which is like a framework for
[00:12:19] Speaker A: running
[00:12:20] Speaker B: influencer marketing.
[00:12:21] Speaker A: Yeah, it's a framework we developed. Yeah. So look, when we started Influence, when we started the company back in 2008, it looked. Influencer marketing looked very different.
[00:12:31] Speaker B: Oh, yeah,
[00:12:32] Speaker A: There. There wasn't any sophisticated creator platforms or there wasn't any measurement standards or even, you know, consistent approaches to compensation and usage rights, etc. So over the years, I feel like the. The industry is becoming much more complex. And so we noticed that brands were approaching influencer marketing like a series of campaigns. Right.
Rather than like a structured discipline. So that's kind of why we establish. That's the reasoning why we established the IC4 model. And it's really just, it's. It's interconnected stages. Right. So the first one is cultural intelligence. We touched on that just a little bit. You know, it's like before we start making sure that we're selecting creators, you know, not just based on, like, follower count, etc. But we're really looking at the audience behavior and the communities and the emerging conversations that are happening.
And so we really try to understand not just who the audience is following, but why they trust certain voices and what matters to them. So it's really understanding what's happening within a specific brand's ethos before we decide to make decisions on creators. The second one is creator collaboration. It's about identifying creators who are genuinely aligned with the brand. And the third is campaign architecture. And that's where we connect.
That's where we connect everything to the business objective. Right. So we, you know, that's where the strategy comes in, in terms of creators, platforms, content formats, messag distributions, et cetera. It's just not about individual posts. It's really about designing an integrated program. And then the fourth is about continuous optimization.
I think it's, that's the difference between traditional, traditional influencer campaigns and a more performance driven or oriented approach. So we analyze what's working, what needs to be changed, what creators and what creative is really working or resonating and then we try to improve upon that performance as we go.
[00:15:07] Speaker B: Yeah, and I think you also mentioned earlier like paid ads was starting to mix into that as well.
[00:15:12] Speaker A: Yes. Yep.
[00:15:13] Speaker B: Oh God, I love that.
[00:15:14] Speaker A: And that's what, and that's what, that's really where the paid ads come in into the continuous optimization.
[00:15:21] Speaker B: Yeah. Because you're able to like analyze like what performed well and then you can try to like reverse engineer it and then like replicate like performance
[00:15:28] Speaker A: trying to make it scalable and repeatable. Right. Based upon specific assets that are working well. And we do that in paid, and we do that with the paid media.
[00:15:38] Speaker B: Interesting. Because I know like a lot of influencer marketing agencies are really just going to focus on like, hey, we're going to link you up some creators, you know, we're going to give you a little bit support, but they're not thinking like the long term vision, like how do we amplify this, how do we keep that momentum going? It's like they kind of leave it at that in a way.
[00:15:55] Speaker A: Right. And I think what we try to do with this IC4 model is we rely heavily on our past performance and the thousands of creators that we've worked with to give us a baseline in terms of, you know, creator compensation and you know, what works and what doesn't work, et cetera, content, formats, etcetera.
[00:16:19] Speaker B: Yeah. So you have a lot of data that you can base yourself off.
[00:16:21] Speaker A: Exactly.
[00:16:22] Speaker B: Create better campaigns. I love that.
Just as we wrap things up, one thing I talked about like long term, like really quickly I want to touch back onto that because a lot of brands approach influencer marketing as you were saying, like maybe like a one off like media buy, they find a creator, they pay for a post, they move on if that doesn't work and then they just like rinse and repeat that same like process. But I feel like there is a more strategic, longer term kind of approach to that and I'd be kind of curious to hear how that approach looks like. And what kind of results is that like compounding approach actually produce compared to just like hey, pay, get resolved, pay and Then just like the transactional model, I think that's probably the best way phrase it.
[00:17:02] Speaker A: Yeah, I think, you know, one of the biggest mistakes that a brand can make is like treating influencer marketing as a transaction.
And you know, they find a creator, they negotiate a fee, they publish a post and then they move on and they may hire them again or not.
I, while I think there is a place for that, I think that you know, like, like around product launches or specific, you know, tent poles or cultural moments, I think the opportunity comes when a brand thinks about creators from the get go as a strategic partner because there's the relationship. So when creators work with a brand over time they develop a deeper understanding of the product or the service right in the audience and their audience has a, you know, they, they know that the creator has worked with the brand before. So it's more credible. Right. It leads to more, it's just more natural, more credible storytelling.
And I think the audience is also have an opportunity to see the relationship with the brand develop.
So I think, I think that there's learning too. I think, you know, first is relationship and second, there's learning. With the one off campaign, you may learn
[00:18:22] Speaker B: like
[00:18:22] Speaker A: a particular creator and his, the content performed well, but if you have an ongoing program, I think you can build on them, right. You can take what worked or what didn't work and you can test different formats, different messaging, you know, different distribution strategies.
So that's what I think. I think that, you know, we are moving more and more to working with creators more as an ambassadorship versus one off posts.
[00:18:54] Speaker B: Yeah, that's interesting. And I was like thinking when you were saying that I'm not an E Commerce or branding expert by any means, but one of the thing I was thinking about is there's like this one big brand like the gym space called gymshark if I remember correctly, if that rings like a bell. And I feel like they've done like a really good job at that where like everyone is basically ambassadors of their brand and they've built like that relationship like a lot of people where they're consistently being shown like throughout any content that they post, whether there is a partnership going or whether there is not. It just looks like they've, they've built a pretty good like influencer marketing system, I would say. Not sure if you would agree with me. I'm not,
[00:19:32] Speaker A: I do agree. Yeah. I think that you know, over time you're building, you know, you're building relationships, you're building a library of creative assets, stronger ties with the audience and just a much better understanding of what actually drives results.
[00:19:49] Speaker B: Yeah. And if you create a really great relationship, these influencers might just continue promoting your product without trying to get something out of it. I mean,
[00:19:57] Speaker A: most
[00:19:57] Speaker B: people want to get a return, but that's kind of my perspective. I love that. Paula, as, as we wrap things up, one of the things I always like to do is for like any brand out there, companies like, hey, you know, we want to have some good influencer like marketing process. Like how do we look at doing that? Is there maybe like two, three piece of advice that you would leave the audience with if they're trying to be better with their influencer marketing here?
[00:20:20] Speaker A: Yeah, I think that if you were looking to, you know, get in to influencer marketing, I think that you have to really do, you really do have to do some research first in terms of, you know, understanding the marketplace, understanding who provides the services, you know, what types it types it. Like if you're going to work with an agency who provides what, what type of service are you looking for? Are you looking for like a self service program where you can run the program yourself?
Are you looking for more of a managed service program where someone's really going to act like your team?
That would be us, like we act as someone's team and we do use different platforms. But you know, if so I think that's one of the biggest questions, you know, do you want to handle it internally or do you want to work with a team that can help you? And number two is understanding your audience and what, what, you know, where they are and you know, what creators, what influencers work best. And I think, you know, it's always like, I think it's like testing and then keep refining your approach.
And I think that's really all part of the IC4 model is, you know, you're testing, you're learning, you're continuing to test over time.
[00:21:48] Speaker B: I like that because you seem to have a philosophy around like research, getting as much data as possible and then like improving upon that. I mean, I know you've been doing that for a while, so you have a lot of data under the hood, but I love that. No, this was really great. We haven't had anyone like the influencer marketing side of things. So I definitely learned a couple things that I think perhaps could be applicable in a couple different ways here. But for anyone that wants to like get in touch with you, Paula, what's kind of the best way to do that? Because I know you're in a couple platform.
[00:22:14] Speaker A: Yeah, they can reach out to me on LinkedIn. They can DM me on LinkedIn, or they could just email me at Paul intuitionmediagroup.com and also on our website, we have a let's talk button. They can just click that and we'll get pinged.
[00:22:30] Speaker B: You got a newsletter, right, as well that you mentioned?
[00:22:32] Speaker A: We also have a newsletter on Substack. Yes, we we publish a Substack monthly.
[00:22:37] Speaker B: Perfect. But we're going to put that newsletter as well all in the show Notes if anyone wants to reach out if they need any help with influencer marketing here. But really appreciate your time here. Paula, to our listeners, if you've enjoyed this episode, don't forget to subscribe, like, comment, review all that fun stuff. Reach out to Paula here if you need some help with influencer marketing. And until then, keep pushing and we'll see in the next one.